“Mom,” Emily whispered, “you have to understand something first.
“Just tell me who the parents are!
Emily started crying even more.
“They’re not two different men.
I stared at her.
What?
Sarah covered her face.
Our babies have the same father.
For several seconds, I couldn’t breathe.
Then I slowly turned to Robert.
My husband remained silent by the stairs, his face completely discolored.
“Robert,” I whispered, “tell me it’s not what I’m thinking.
He opened his mouth, but not a word came out.
“ANSWER ME!
It wasn’t me, Margaret!
THEN WHO?!
Emily stood between us.
—Michael.
I was frozen.
What Michael?
“Uncle Michael. Robert’s friend.
I felt the ground disappear under my feet.
Michael Bennett was thirty-four years old. He had been Robert’s best friend for almost fifteen years.
He attended our Christmas dinners, helped us move into our house and always carried birthday gifts for the girls.