But our mothers reacted strangely when we mentioned the fertility clinic.
My mother, Margaret, became visibly uncomfortable when I told her our donor’s name.
“Daniel?” she repeated.
Then she asked whether we knew anything about his family.
Emily’s mother, Helen, seemed equally unsettled.
She even suggested choosing another donor.
We assumed they were simply nervous about becoming grandmothers.
We couldn’t have been more mistaken.
One rainy Tuesday morning, the clinic called and requested that we come in immediately.
Dr. Harrison was waiting in a private consultation room.
Two monitors displayed detailed genetic reports.
“Your babies show an unexpected level of genetic similarity,” he explained.
Emily frowned.
“Of course they do. They have the same father.”
“That explains some of it,” he replied. “But not all.”
He hesitated before continuing.
“One possibility is that you two are biologically related.”
We stared at him.
“That’s impossible,” I said. “We have different parents.”