In that locker, investigators found old donation envelopes, a broken cash box, and a stack of letters Robert had written but never sent, each one attempting to arrange the narrative so that Emily would remain the convenient criminal in a story that needed one.
He had never needed her in an actual prison. He had only needed the town to believe she was there, and a town that trusted a grieving mother with a tissue under her eye had done the rest without being asked.
The first official interview lasted four hours. Robert blamed Diane. Diane blamed panic. Both of them blamed Emily for leaving, for enlisting without their permission, for abandoning the family. Sheriff Daniels told Emily about that part later with a bitterness he didn’t try to conceal.
“They said you abandoned them,” he told her.
Emily almost laughed. Instead she looked at the floor of the interview room and thought about all the nights she had sat on a cot overseas writing to people who were using her silence as raw material for their story.